Skip to content
AI

The Gatekeepers’ Crusade

Legacy media executives and best-selling authors are entirely free to boycott whatever technology they wish from the comfort of their advances and agency contracts. What they do not get to do is pretend they speak for the rest of us.

How Legacy Publishing’s Anti-AI Orthodoxy Pulls Up the Ladder on Working-Class and Disabled Creatives

When best-selling thriller novelist Andrea Bartz tells the creative world to "stay as far away" from generative AI "as humanly possible," declaring that "there’s no ethical way to use generative AI," she adds a brief, telling caveat: "I realise that’s a privileged position."

It is the most honest sentence in an otherwise deeply self-serving campaign.
Across Substack newsletters, Westminster lobbying rooms, and curated "Creators Emergency Summits," a well-connected coalition of legacy media executives, corporate trade bodies, and Big Five authors has appointed itself the moral conscience of the creative industries. Positioned as a grassroots defence of the struggling artist against Silicon Valley rapacity, their crusade demands a blanket ethical boycott of generative tools and a legislative settlement that funnels AI licensing fees straight back into traditional collecting societies and publishing conglomerates.

Yet when you examine who is speaking, who funds their infrastructure, and who actually collects the cheques, a stark contradiction emerges. This is not a movement representing "all creatives." It is an exercise in institutional protectionism, one that treats technological democratisation as an existential threat to traditional gatekeeping, while casually erasing the material realities of working-class, minority, and disabled artists.

Follow the Money: Who Actually Profits from the "Creators’" Victory?

In media coverage, the Bartz v. Anthropic class action is routinely presented as a David-and-Goliath triumph for individual writers. A closer look at the ledger reveals a far more familiar corporate hierarchy.

First, the legal precedent itself is routinely misrepresented. The presiding judge did not rule that training AI on books is illegal or unethical; in fact, the court held that training models on lawfully purchased books constitutes permissible fair use. Anthropic settled for $1.5 billion because it had downloaded books from pirated shadow libraries rather than acquiring them through commercial channels.
Second, look at where that $1.5 billion actually goes:

  • The Legal Class: Class-action attorneys sought over $300 million in fees and litigation costs, earning in a few billable hours what the average commercial author makes in a year.
  • The Corporate Conglomerates: The largest institutional beneficiaries of the settlement pool are multinational publishing houses: Penguin Random House, HarperCollins, Hachette, Wiley, Springer Nature, claiming payouts across tens of thousands of registered titles.
  • The Individual Writer: After legal deductions and 50/50 contractual splits with publishers, an individual author receives roughly 1,200 - 2,200 USD per eligible book.

Meanwhile, the public faces of this movement are hardly operating on the margins. Bartz commands six-figure incomes built on Penguin Random House advances, Reese’s Book Club endorsements, and Hollywood option deals; her co-plaintiffs write for Viking and Hachette with major studio adaptations behind them. In Britain, the campaign is steered by veteran broadcast executives, corporate media consultants, and collecting-society chief executives whose explicit policy goal is requiring every creator online to register with and pay dues to institutional licensing bodies.

When those sitting comfortably inside the fortress announce that nobody needs tools to scale the walls, they are not protecting the commons. They are protecting their moat.

The Hidden Economics of Gatekeeping

The moral demand to "avoid AI entirely" rests on an unspoken assumption: that every serious artist has access to capital, institutional backing, and a paid production team.

A Big Five author does not design their own book cover, typeset their own interior, engineer their own audiobook, build their own promotional visuals, or fund their own marketing campaigns. A major publisher advances tens of thousands of pounds to hire specialist agencies to do that work for them.
Now consider an independent, working-class author, visual artist, or small autonomous press operating without inherited wealth or corporate advances:

  • Commissioning bespoke cover art, promotional graphics, soundscapes, and multi-format transmedia assets through traditional commercial agencies costs thousands of pounds per release.
  • Traditional publishing houses, overwhelmingly concentrated in London and New York, and notoriously homogeneous in class and background, reject the vast majority of working-class and experimental voices before a manuscript ever reaches an editor.

For decades, cultural gatekeepers maintained their monopoly not because working-class people lacked imagination, but because they lacked the capital required to achieve high-production polish and independent distribution. Open-source, locally hosted generative and computational tools collapse that capital barrier. They allow a single creator or a three-person independent studio to produce visual worlds, sound design, and print-ready artefacts without begging a London literary agent or a Manhattan conglomerate for permission.
To brand those tools inherently "unethical" is to tell working-class and minority creators that unless they can afford to hire traditional industry middlemen, their work deserves to look amateur or remain unseen.

Accessibility Is Not a Moral Compromise

Even more glaring is the total erasure of disabled, neurodivergent, and chronically ill creatives from the "no ethical use" orthodoxy.

For artists living with severe fatigue, mobility impairments, repetitive strain injuries, visual processing challenges, or neurodivergent executive dysfunction, creative labour is not an abstract aesthetic exercise; it is a daily negotiation with physical and cognitive limits. Assistive and generative pipelines, whether used for structural drafting, visual iteration, voice synthesis, or local workflow automation, often represent the difference between sustaining an active artistic practice and being forced out of creative life altogether.

When able-bodied, well-resourced commentators declare from a position of admitted privilege that using generative tools is a moral failing, they impose an ableist purity test on the creative community. True artistic ethics are measured by human agency, creative sovereignty, and honesty of intent, not by whether an artist suffered enough physical pain or spent enough money on legacy contractors to satisfy a trade-union lobbyist.

Sovereignty Over Servitude

At Art of FACELESS, we reject both halves of this false binary. We have no interest in defending the Silicon Valley monopolies, wealth, health and power inequalities that scrape human culture into closed, proprietary black boxes, nor do we accept the paternalism of legacy media elites who claim to speak on our behalf while building new tollbooths around creative expression.
True creative independence requires sovereignty:

  1. Technological Autonomy: Supporting open-source, locally deployed tools that run on the creator’s own hardware, free from corporate surveillance, subscription rent-seeking, and algorithmic censorship.
  2. Direct Distribution: Bypassing both Big Tech platforms and legacy publishing gatekeepers through independent ISBNs, physical print-on-demand, tangible editions, and direct reader relationships.
  3. Class and Disability Solidarity: Defending the right of every working-class, minority, and disabled creator to use whatever tools amplify their voice, without submitting to moral policing from those who already hold the keys to the industry.

Legacy media executives and best-selling authors are entirely free to boycott whatever technology they wish from the comfort of their advances and agency contracts.

What they do not get to do is pretend they speak for the rest of us.


The views and analysis expressed in this editorial represent the independent position of Art of FACELESS and are published in the public interest as commentary on cultural policy, creative economics, and technological access. All references to legal proceedings, public figures, and corporate structures are based on publicly available court records, published interviews, and media reports at the time of publication. This article constitutes opinion and critical commentary rather than legal or financial advice.

Comments are open to registered members of artoffaceless.com

A summary of this piece is published on Substack at artoffaceless.online, where comments will be closed, and Substack users are encouraged to comment on this site regarding this piece, only where it will be curated and independently archived.

Art of FACELESS | Substack
An autonomous publishing imprint and transmedia studio building visceral speculative fiction, transgressive body horror, and sovereign narrative worlds anchored by The Hollow Circuit® Est. 2012. Click to read Art of FACELESS, a Substack publication. Launched a year ago.

Comments

Latest

The Receipt
AI

The Receipt

TXN: /the-receipt Art of FACELESS · punk publishing The Receipt What Your Outrage Actually Costs the Grid Harm = energy × uses That's the missing word from the card. You found it. Now let's add up what it costs, all of it, for all of us. HARM = ENERGY

Members Public

© 2026 Art of FACELESS. All rights reserved.
The Hollow Circuit®, Hyperstition Architecture®, The Veylon Protocol®, and Cognitive Colonisation® are proprietary intellectual property of Art of FACELESS.